Did Malcolm Pein's Endorsement Help Turlov Win FIDE?
By Douglas C. · Fri, 09 Oct 2026
The suspicion that has trailed Timur Turlov's election as FIDE president since the Samarkand General Assembly has now reached the business press. Business Matters, a UK outlet, published a piece on October 9 asking whether the endorsement of English chess figure Malcolm Pein helped put a candidate under Ukrainian sanctions at the head of the world federation.
The suspicion that has trailed Timur Turlov's election as FIDE president since the Samarkand General Assembly has now reached the business press. Business Matters, a UK outlet, published a piece on October 9 asking whether the endorsement of English chess figure Malcolm Pein helped put a candidate under Ukrainian sanctions at the head of the world federation. The article poses questions rather than answers them, and by its own account it rests on no documents and no named sources, but its appearance outside the chess media is a development in itself.
The facts the piece builds on
The established record is not in dispute. In the first round of voting, Turlov, running on a ticket with Viswanathan Anand, received 96 votes. Rosenstein, with Tang as his running mate, got 76, and Büttner, with Pein on his ticket, got 20, with 97 needed to win outright. After Büttner was eliminated, he and Pein backed Turlov. Turlov won the runoff 110 to 85. Business Matters notes that Pein and Turlov were seen raising their hands together after the result, and that Turlov has been under Ukrainian sanctions since 2022.
It also recalls that Pein objected to the election of Kolobkov as a vice president and withdrew from the Council. According to the article, Pein's own position, paraphrased rather than directly quoted, is that his endorsement followed an agreement with Turlov covering suspended teams, compliance with Court of Arbitration for Sport rulings and limits on management posts held per nationality.
What the article suggests, and what it admits
Business Matters asks whether Pein's withdrawal from the Council was a "face-saving gesture" or "political theatre," whether he might be positioning himself for a future role at the European Chess Union, and whether his challenge to ECU president Zurab Azmaiparashvili and his call for an extraordinary assembly could be self-serving. It also notes that Pein has been seen with Dvorkovich several times in Samarkand, and suggests that Dvorkovich's support for Turlov points to Russian influence. It concludes that Pein's backing helped Turlov and sets a "troubling precedent" for British chess.
The piece is candid about the limits of its evidence. It says it has no documents, named sources or federation-level voting data supporting its central suggestion. The first-round totals do not show that Pein's 20 votes moved as a bloc, and the votes belonged to federations, not to the candidates' running mates. There has not found any public evidence of the other elements, including a future ECU role for Pein, sanctions on Turlov by the EU or United States, or the claim that Dvorkovich's support demonstrates Russian influence. Sitting in the same place as someone in Samarkand is not evidence of anything. Business Matters did not report a response from Turlov.
Why it matters even without proof
The arithmetic is the hard part. Turlov won the runoff by 25 votes, 110 to 85, and Büttner's first-round total was 20. Calculation is that Turlov gained 14 votes between rounds and Rosenstein gained 9, while the two rounds differ in total turnout by three. That is consistent with Büttner's 20 votes splitting between the two, but it is not proof of how they split, and no public data shows how Büttner's federations voted in the second round. The endorsement may have mattered as a signal, but the article does not show that it changed the result.
What the piece does capture is how the election's aftermath has been framed. We have previously reported on the Rule 9.8 collusion complaint over the Turlov and Pein handshake, on Pein's criticism of the General Assembly after its quorum failure, and on Rosenstein's CAS case over Turlov's eligibility given the Ukrainian sanctions. Dvorkovich, himself suspended after EU sanctions in July, has said Turlov "had no right to be elected" and that CAS might annul the result.
Nothing in the Business Matters article changes the formal position. Turlov holds the presidency, the vote count stands, and Rosenstein's challenge over Turlov's eligibility is the route by which any of this would be tested. What the article does show is that the questions are no longer confined to chess sites, which makes a response from Pein and Turlov more likely to be demanded than ignored.