Brewing Carlsen Scandal at Total Chess
By Cameron W. · Wed, 18 Nov 2026
Carlsen skipped a game he didn’t need to play. Sutovsky and Niemann call it unsportsmanlike, So defends it, and the organisers back him.
The Fast Classic game was due to start at 18:45 on Tuesday evening in Budapest. Bibisara Assaubayeva sat down at the board and waited. She was there for 15 minutes before the arbiters awarded her the win. Her opponent, Magnus Carlsen, had gone to speak to the chief arbiter and then left the hall without playing. A quiet knockout game for places 17 to 20 has since turned into the biggest argument of the Total Chess pilot.
What happened
Carlsen led Assaubayeva 11.5-0.5 after the blitz and rapid games, so the day was already his. Each day is worth 20 points, with 8 of them for the Fast Classic game, and the scores reset on day two. Instead of sitting down, Carlsen went to the chief arbiter, and after a lengthy discussion he left without playing. Assaubayeva was awarded the 8 points. That made the final score 11.5-8.5. Chief arbiter Anastasia Sorokina said Carlsen had asked what the penalty for not playing would be. Because the game was not played, he lost no rating points, but he gave up the eight points on offer.
Carlsen's reasoning
Speaking to Norway's TV 2, Carlsen said the match was already over and that skipping the game cost him only "a totally useless game." He said games played after a match is decided should be unrated, as has traditionally been the case, and that he could understand playing for points in a true World Championship but not in a show event. Before the game he had said he was not looking forward to playing classical chess in this setting, and called the situation awkward.
The rating question
Almost everyone noticed the rating angle. Carlsen won none of his ten Fast Classic games in the group stage, drawing nine and losing one to Haik Martirosyan. That cost him 21.8 live classical rating points and left him at 2801.2. He was at risk of falling below 2800 for the first time since 2009. A loss would also have left him only 0.7 points ahead of Hikaru Nakamura, and Fabiano Caruana was closing in. Wesley So, the main defender of the decision, argued that Carlsen could gain only one rating point from a win but lose nine from a defeat. Carlsen himself framed the decision as a matter of principle rather than rating.
What the rules say
That is where the argument sharpens. FIDE's handbook says games played after a match is decided shall not be rated, but this can be waived on prior request. Total Chess received a waiver and told players at the pre-event technical meeting that all games would be played and rated. The terms agreed at that meeting about games after a match is decided have not been published. Hans Niemann said it had been agreed at the meeting that such games could count, and that a lower-rated opponent who forfeited would have faced consequences.
The critics
FIDE's Emil Sutovsky called it "pathetic unsportsmanlike conduct." India's Olympiad captain Srinath Narayanan wrote that "Dignity and courtesy took a fall long before the rating." Niemann argued that any other player who forfeited would have lost the match, and called the treatment favouritism towards one player. He pointed to Carlsen's 2024 dress-code dispute and the shared World Blitz title with Ian Nepomniachtchi as earlier examples. He said forfeiting was disrespectful to the organisers and the opponent, and that he would never make such a decision himself. Niemann and Carlsen have a long and very public history that goes back to the Sinquefield Cup in 2022, which readers should keep in mind when weighing the favouritism claim.
The defenders
Not everyone was critical. As well as So, Ian Nepomniachtchi said he envied Carlsen's position, since his big lead let him skip the game without affecting the overall result. English grandmaster David Howell, a longtime friend of Carlsen, responded with a sardonic congratulation to Assaubayeva.
The organisers' position
Total Chess founder Kjell Madland stood by the result. He said Carlsen was entitled to skip the game, that nothing had been changed, and that the rules were the same for everyone. He called the Budapest event a pilot and a learning exercise, said the organisers have no predetermined view that the rules need to change, and said they want feedback from players and arbiters first. Any refinements would come before the inaugural edition in March 2027. Chess.com suggests the rule may be clarified before then. The regulations allow organisers to apply a fee, which would be their decision, and no fine has been announced.
What comes next
Assaubayeva has not responded publicly in any report I could find. On Wednesday the scores reset to zero, and the match picks up again. The day starts with the blitz games at 15:00 CET, with the Fast Classic game at 18:45. Carlsen leads, and Assaubayeva has the chance to win the second day and force an Armageddon game. Total Chess built the pilot to find out which rules need work. On the first day of the knockout, it found one.
Sources
- Chess.com, "Firouzja, Giri Lead Total Chess Semifinals; Carlsen Forfeits Final Game"
- World Chess, "Carlsen Forfeits Game To Leave Total Chess In A Total Mess"
- ChessBase, "Firouzja and Giri win opening sets, Carlsen sparks controversy"
- ChessBase India, "Semi-finals Day 1: Carlsen forfeits, Giri and Firouzja lead"
- Daijiworld, "Carlsen forfeits game to protect rating, sparks chess controversy"
- Reporter World News, "Magnus Carlsen forfeits game against Bibisara Assaubayeva, sparks sportsmanship row"
- FIDE, "Giri and Firouzja take first-day leads in Total Chess Semifinals"
- Wikipedia, "Carlsen-Niemann controversy"